Penis Pump Guide : How to choose one

So,you have decided to buy a pump but not able to decide which one to buy.

My guide will help you in that regard.

Bathmate vs Penomet: An in Depth Comparison

First off, the Penomet pump is the cheaper of the two, so if you are on a tight budget and price is the deciding factor, then you have your decision made for you. However, we would also highly recommend the Bathmate Xtreme pump, as the size gains are fast and obvious.

Bathmate also have more affordable options than the Xtreme range, so don’t forget to check those out too in case they fall within your budget.

Both Penomet and Bathmate are great penis pumps, so if you pick either one you are making a good choice. We just wanted to compare the two to help you pick the right one for you.

In this article we will provide you with a comprehensive overview of both pumps, as well as comparing and contrasting them so that you get the best overview possible. By the end of this article you will be an expert – and you will know which one is right for you.


So which is better, Bathmate or Penomet?

This is the leading question in the comparison of the two models. Both will give you similar results, provided you use them regularly over a couple of months. They are both water pumps from top brands, and are therefore very similar.

However, there are a couple of things you need to take into consideration when choosing between the two.



This basically just comes down to what you can afford. If you are tight on money but are very desperate for those important size gains, then Penomet is your pump. Bathmate also have some more affordable options, such as the Bathmate Hercules.

If you do have a larger budget and want to spend a bit more, then we would recommend the Bathmate Hydromax line. It is a bit more expensive, but the suction is more powerful and the line comes in different sizes to fit everyone.


Which is the best package?

If you are going to go for a Penomet pump, we would recommend the premium package. This includes five gaiters that can alter the amount of pressure being applied to your penis. There are also lots of little freebies in the pack too, which can come in handy. You can find a full comparison among 3 top penis pumps here.

For the Bathmate pumps, we would recommend the Bathmate Xtreme. This pump is extremely powerful, and like the Penomet premium package, it comes with a load of accessories. These include things like cleaning fluid and lube.


Make sure you know your erect size

This is super important when choosing a pump. You want something that fits your natural size, but will a little extra room for growth. If you get one that fits too snuggly, you wont be able to grow into it.


Check out the table below for a size guide.


Starting Size Consider Don’t Consider
7 inches or bigger Bathmate Goliath

Penomet Premium

Bathmate X40

Bathmate Hercules

Bathmate X30

6.6 – 6.75 inches Any of the pumps N/A
5.25 – 6.5 inches Bathmate Hercules

Bathmate X30

Penomet Premium

Bathmate Goliath
5.25 inches or smaller Bathmate Hercules

Bathmate X30

Penomet Premium

Bathmate Goliath

Bathmate X40



The Penomet pump has five gaiters, so you can personalise the amount of pressure you apply to your penis. Start off gently and work your way up.

With the Bathmate X40 pump, you will want to take things extra slow, as they are super powerful.

Both pumps are safe to use, and will not exert a force greater than you can handle. There is also the safety valve that you can press to release the pressure if it becomes too much for whatever reason.

If you want to maximise the pressure, you will need to create the tightest possible seal around your body. To achieve this, you will need to shave or trim your pubic hair.


Which one is easier to use?


Both are used in the same way, so in that sense, they are just as easy to use. At first there is a bit of a learning curve in getting the maximum pressure each time you use the pump, but this just comes with a little practice.


If you use the pump every day, it won’t be long before it becomes second nature!

Once the pumps are sealed to your body, they become hands-free. However, the Penomet is a little bigger and heavier and can drop down if the strong seal is not maintained.


Bathmate, on the other hand, have come up with a solution to this. Some of their pumps come with a shower strap, which holds up the tip of the pump to stop it sagging down.


Water retention


Using water based penis pumps can result in water retention. However, this is completely harmless, and goes away on its own.


This problem is less common with Penomet and Bathmate pumps, as they are built with such high quality materials.


Are they comfortable?


Bathmate have tried to make some of their pumps even more comfortable with a comfort ring that rests against your body. However, we found that this didn’t make much of a difference, as all of the pumps from Bathmate and Penomet alike were very comfortable to use.


Bathmate’s advantage


The Bathmate pumps come all in one piece, so you don’t have to waste time detaching and reattaching extra pieces. This combined with the shower strap enable you to do stretches and exercises while wearing the device to increase your size gains.


Are they easy to clean?


These pumps are pretty easy to clean – the premium packages even come with their own cleaning fluid. You need to clean it regularly, and rinse it out each time you use it. Those long skinny washing up brushes are useful for cleaning the inside.


What if I already have a pump?


Then you are all set! The only time you would need to buy another one is if you outgrow your old one. Just simply buy the next size up and keep going!


Final Thoughts and Where to buy

Both the Penomet and the Bathmate pumps are a great buy. They are both top quality brands whose products get results. Our top choice is the Bathmate Xtreme as it has the strongest suction.

However, if the Bathmate Xtreme is too expensive for you, then any of the other more affordable pumps are just as good, such as the Penomet full package or the Bathmate X30 or X40.


Always buy from the official website rather buying from platform like eBay and Amazon.